essie gel couture fairy tailor VS sheer fantasy

essie gel couture fairy tailor bottle VS essie gel couture sheer fantasy

Updated 2025.11.24. This post contains affiliate links. If you buy something through these links, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. 

In this post, you’re going to see a comparison between two lovely sheer essie gel couture shades. I love both of these colors and enjoy them equally as part of my collection.

essie gel couture is my favorite long wearing nail polish line. I regularly wear these shades when I’m not swatching colors for the blog and I also seek them out when I’m making purchases for colors to feature.

What I love about this line is that it’s economical in that it doesn’t need a base coat. It’s just the color and the top coat. I also love the bottle design and most of all, the formula is reliable.

With good manicure prep, gel couture shades do last longer than your standard nail colors.

essie gel couture is now also known as gel by essie, but, however it’s branded, it’s a long-wear essie polish that doesn’t require a UV lamp.

gel couture fairy tailor is an essie best seller.

gel couture sheer fantasy is also an essie best seller.

Both fairy tailor and sheer fantasy have these facts in common: 

  • Made by essie

  • Long wear formula

  • Sheer finish

However, because they’re both best selling sheers from the same brand in the same formula, they’re often compared and contrasted to one another.

To clear up any confusion between what is what, below you’ll see the differences between essie gel couture fairy tailor and essie gel couture sheer fantasy. 

To begin, you’ll see fairy tailor swatches, followed by sheer fantasy swatches, ending with a final comparison photo, with fairy tailor shown on the top in all images.

Starting with essie gel couture fairy tailor swatches:

essie gel couture fairy tailor swatch
essie gel couture fairy tailor swatch

Next, essie gel couture sheer fantasy swatches:

essie gel couture sheer fantasy swatch
essie gel couture sheer fantasy swatch

Now for the final comparison photo:

essie gel couture fairy tailor swatch VS essie gel couture sheer fantasy swatch

There is only one slight difference between these two colors.

fairy tailor is a light, warm, pink nude. You could also call it a light neutral beige with pink undertones.

sheer fantasy is a cool light milky pink. You could also call it a sheer pink with white undertones. It’s so milky it reminds me of essie mademoiselle.

Overall, the main difference is that fairy tailor is more of a nude and sheer fantasy is more of a pink.

Both of these can be worn on their own or a base for nail art - my favorite way to wear them is as the foundation for a classic or ombré french tip.

So, what are you in the mood for? A nude leaning pink or a milky pink?

If you’re looking for a warm neutral sheer that’s a touch pink, get essie fairy tailor at Ulta.

If you’re looking for a light pink sheer, get essie sheer fantasy at Ulta.

For best results, pair these shades with clean dry nails and the essie gel couture top coat.

Other Articles You May Enjoy:

As an Ulta Affiliate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. 

Did you enjoy this article? Tap follow on Instagram for more great content!

Author Bio: Amanda Meder

Amanda is the founder and lead writer of Lots of Lacquer, which she launched in 2021 to share her love of nail care and nail art.

With over 25 years of experience in all things nails, she creates tutorials, reviews, and guides that are easy to follow and genuinely helpful because she tests every product and technique herself.

Amanda began blogging in 2012, and before diving into the nail world full-time, she spent years teaching in the private sector, government, academic, and nonprofit settings. This experience honed her ability to explain things clearly and make learning enjoyable.

She holds a B.S. and M.S. in scientific fields, bringing a grounded, thoughtful approach to everything she shares.

Her goal is simple: to make nail care approachable, fun, and reliable for everyone.

https://www.lotsoflacquer.com/our-story
Previous
Previous

essie geranium Swatches and Review

Next
Next

essie good as gold Review and Swatches